Why does the Arbitration page list only one party to arbitration issue. It would seem that it should list both (all) parties. No?
If there is a dispute between two or more editors, then this is called a "Mediation" issue and is listed on [[Wikipedia:Requests for Mediation]]. In the case of charges against one editor, it goes on [[Wikipedia:Requests for Arbitration]]. The person or persons making the charges need not have been involved in any direct disputation with the person they are charging, but they might have been. In your case, Viajero charged you with repeated disservice to Wikipedia over many months and I plan to support that charge with many examples when the arbitrators decide to hear the case.
I notice you just added an example in [[Israeli West Bank barrier]] where your edit summary "replace image with one agreed to in talk on 26 Jul 2004" shows your lack of integrity since two complementary images were agreed to after a long negotiation, and you know that. Next stunt like that and I will block you again.
Zero.
__________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Yahoo! Mail - 50x more storage than other providers! http://promotions.yahoo.com/new_mail
Zero wrote:
If there is a dispute between two or more editors, then this is called a "Mediation" issue and is listed on [[Wikipedia:Requests for Mediation]]. In the case of charges against one editor, it goes on [[Wikipedia:Requests for Arbitration]]. The person or persons making the charges need not have been involved in any direct disputation with the person they are charging, but they might have been.
That's not how it works, or certainly not how it should. Almost every case has two sides, both usually believing that the other is the only party at fault. Mediation is as important in a case of "charges against one editor" as otherwise. Although it certainly makes it difficult if one side won't acknowledge that they might just be at fault too (and that goes for /either/ side).
In the (rarer) case that an issue is totally one sided there is still a place for mediation, negotiation and genuine attempts to reach understanding.
Equally, arbitration can be necessary in a dispute between two or more editors if mediation fails. It's quite possible for the arbitration committee to look at a case and decide both sides are at fault.
I notice you just added an example in [[Israeli West Bank barrier]] where your edit summary "replace image with one agreed to in talk on 26 Jul 2004" shows your lack of integrity since two complementary images were agreed to after a long negotiation, and you know that. Next stunt like that and I will block you again.
As an administrator you do not have the authority to block a logged in user except in the cases outlined in the blocking policy - which basically comes down to instances of simple vandalism. If you follow through on this threat I would say the other party is likely to have a good case for taking /you/ to arbitration.
--sannse
--- zero 0000 nought_0000@yahoo.com wrote:
I notice you just added an example in [[Israeli West Bank barrier]] where your edit summary "replace image with one agreed to in talk on 26 Jul 2004" shows your lack of integrity since two complementary images were agreed to after a long negotiation, and you know that. Next stunt like that and I will block you again.
Zero.
QUOTES: Ok, we have permission to use the third image. I reduced it to the same width as the wall picture. These two pictures together give a reasonable overview of most of the barrier. The barrier near Jenin, northern West Bank, July 2003
Great work! Thank you! Jayjg 16:17, 22 Jul 2004 (UTC)
Way to go. Stargoat 17:45, 22 Jul 2004 (UTC)
Does anyone know how to get these pictures into the main body of the article? Jayjg 05:05, 26 Jul 2004 (UTC)
I can do it, maybe tomorrow. --Zero 09:27, 26 Jul 2004 (UTC)
Zero,
You might have thanked the person for doing what you said you would try to get to and had not done.
Lance6wINS
__________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Yahoo! Mail - 50x more storage than other providers! http://promotions.yahoo.com/new_mail _______________________________________________ WikiEN-l mailing list WikiEN-l@Wikipedia.org http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikien-l
__________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? New and Improved Yahoo! Mail - Send 10MB messages! http://promotions.yahoo.com/new_mail