Hi!
On Thu, 15 Jul 2004 07:48:05 -0600, Fred Bauder wrote:
Attempts by the Chinese government to edit
Wikipedia articles on China would be highly counter-productive and
embarrassing for many of the same reasons that apply to an individual user.
Not too sure about that - I am sure that many articles about China could be
edited in a quite NPOV way even by the Chinese government. However, articles
about current Chinese politics would not be among these articles.
Same way, CoS should maybe not edit articles about the CoS, because their way
of dealing with anything that does not agree with their point of view is quite
notorious, and, let me put this carefully, does not exactly seem to agree well
with the principle of NPOV.
The comparison with say, Roman Catholics, does not hold too much water,
because let's face it, there are quite a few Catholics who do not necessarily
agree with everything that comes from Rome; something that is said not to be
particularly good if you are a member of CoS. (Or not even a member, for that
matter.) Also, Rome has stopped burning their critics for quite a while now,
too.
Alex
--
If you don't go over the top,
you can't see what's on the other side.
--- Jim Steinman ---
Alex' Assorted Homepages:
www.alexsite.de