--- On Fri 11/07, Arvind Narayanan < arvindn@meenakshi.cs.iitm.ernet.in > wrote: From: Arvind Narayanan [mailto: arvindn@meenakshi.cs.iitm.ernet.in]
The person making the allegations has 3 usernames LibertarianAnarchist, Democrate2003 and Conradx. I'll call them LA for short. The above articles are the only ones LA has ever edited.
This is rubbish. Any admin can check up the IP address and you will find that I have nothing to do with Democrate2003 or Conradx.
On the actual points.
You keep deleting the point about Abdul Kalam being a Muslim candidate of BJP.
You either pretend that VR Krishna Iyer was never a Minister in a Communist Govt or you are ignorant. Which of the two is it?
You pretend that VR Krishna Iyer was not the Communist Party candidate for Presidency. This is a FACT.
The story about the tea vendor and the brawl was proven wrong when journalists phoned up the person mentioned as the witness in the email that did the rounds. You are clearly lying by pretending that you do not know that.
On the "alleged" state sponsored genocide. Alleged by whom? By you and your communist friends? If you have EVIDENCE, feel free to present it. Once established, I have no objection to it being posted.
The key word is "alleged." You've been going around posting your "allegations." That is not what an encyclopedia is about. By the same logic, why did you object to my allegation of the genocide in Jedwabne? It is a POV, isn't it?
To the admins, if there are 25000 allegations, will all be represented? Let us also not pretend that I am using Communist to broadbrush you. You've deliberately worded it to sound as if Krishna Iyer is merely "considered" by some people to be a Marxist when in reality, he was an active participant in the Marxist ministry.
I also suggest you apologize for claiming that I am Democrate2003 and Conradx.
-a
_______________________________________________ No banners. No pop-ups. No kidding. Introducing My Way - http://www.myway.com
On Sat, Nov 08, 2003 at 12:06:26AM -0500, libertarian wrote:
--- On Fri 11/07, Arvind Narayanan < arvindn@meenakshi.cs.iitm.ernet.in > wrote: From: Arvind Narayanan [mailto: arvindn@meenakshi.cs.iitm.ernet.in]
The person making the allegations has 3 usernames LibertarianAnarchist, Democrate2003 and Conradx. I'll call them LA for short. The above articles are the only ones LA has ever edited.
This is rubbish. Any admin can check up the IP address and you will find that I have nothing to do with Democrate2003 or Conradx.
That proves nothing at all. You could be using one username from home and one from work etc.
All 3 usernames are newly created and all edit the same articles; your opinions are all the same, and your rants are *very* similar to those of Conradx on [[User_talk:Angela]], for example. Against all this evidence we have only your word, which counts for nothing (to me at least).
Also note that I'm not the only one to think so. On my talk page you will see:
It is only one person, of course, so presumably it will settle down soon enough either way. -- VV 09:43, 1 Nov 2003 (UTC)
So I still continue to assume you are the same person.
I also suggest you apologize for claiming that I am Democrate2003 and Conradx.
Why?? I wouldn't feel insulted if someone claims I'm someone else; if you do, that's your problem. You've already claimed that Fred's opinion of you constitutes slander; so of course I'm not surprised you're outraged (or pretend to be) by what I claimed, but again, I see no reason to change my opinion.
And by the way, I have absolutely no inclination to get into an argument with you about who is a communist and who isn't. You can assume that I am a communist, if it will make you happy.
Cheers, Arvind
Arvind Narayanan wrote:
On Sat, Nov 08, 2003 at 12:06:26AM -0500, libertarian wrote:
--- On Fri 11/07, Arvind Narayanan < arvindn@meenakshi.cs.iitm.ernet.in > wrote: From: Arvind Narayanan [mailto: arvindn@meenakshi.cs.iitm.ernet.in]
The person making the allegations has 3 usernames LibertarianAnarchist, Democrate2003 and Conradx. I'll call them LA for short. The above articles are the only ones LA has ever edited.
This is rubbish. Any admin can check up the IP address and you will find that I have nothing to do with Democrate2003 or Conradx.
That proves nothing at all. You could be using one username from home and one from work etc.
As much as I may have serious differences with Libertarian's substantive points, I don't think that pursuing the multiple identities issue will be fruitful. The fact has been denied, and he is now aware that such a practice is not at all appreciated on Wikipedia. If his denial is correct then it's a non-issue. If his denial is less than honest, he should be allowed the opportunity to quietly stop using the identities without further ado.
Ec