On 14/09/05, Sam Korn smoddy@gmail.com wrote:
PWDS encourages revert warring. Do you really, honestly, think that is a good thing?
I balance this against the benefit of ending AfD. Personally, I judge the benefits of PWDS to far outweigh the downsides.
Of course, others will disagree. And we probably will never get rid of AfD without consensus, which we'll never get, as plenty of people think AfD is perfect. So this conversation is probably pointless :-).
Dan
PS Someone also mentioned rc patrolling: as I've said before, I don't see how PWDS would be a hinderance. Unless someone as made a well-reasoned justification for the blanking on the Talk page and signposted that in the edit summary, revert.
On 9/15/05, Dan Grey dangrey@gmail.com wrote:
PS Someone also mentioned rc patrolling: as I've said before, I don't see how PWDS would be a hinderance. Unless someone as made a well-reasoned justification for the blanking on the Talk page and signposted that in the edit summary, revert.
Yes. Precisely. You have highlighted *exactly* what is wrong with it. You need to go and check it. Time spent checking the validity of a deletion means more "X IS A PENIS"es will get through.
Sam