"Andrew Gray"
How many of our contributors are here to write about what they know, not primarily here to build "an encyclopedia"?
The argument on finitude applies much better to individuals than to the project as a whole. A natural "encyclopedist" would be someone willing to write stubs, at least, outside their comfort zone of familiar knowledge. So the point becomes that there are relatively few of those. Yes, but WP has actually come this far because such people are many more than Britannica's view would suggest. Professional reference book writers are not so many, though I did meet one at Wikimania. The issue is of recruiting and retaining the right people, who can learn on the job. The scope of Wikipedia is not really the point.
Charles
----------------------------------------- Email sent from www.virginmedia.com/email Virus-checked using McAfee(R) Software and scanned for spam
On 13/10/2007, charles.r.matthews@ntlworld.com charles.r.matthews@ntlworld.com wrote:
The argument on finitude applies much better to individuals than to the project as a whole. A natural "encyclopedist" would be someone willing to write stubs, at least, outside their comfort zone of familiar knowledge. So the point becomes that there are relatively few of those. Yes, but WP has actually come this far because such people are many more than Britannica's view would suggest. Professional reference book writers are not so many, though I did meet one at Wikimania. The issue is of recruiting and retaining the right people, who can learn on the job. The scope of Wikipedia is not really the point.
Again, I don't disagree with you. I'm just saying we're going to slow down our growth rate as we transition from "the dilettantes' work is done" to "it's the hard-core encyclopedists from here on in", simply because there's a much smaller pool of them to work with and the work they're doing is a touch more time-consuming.
A lot of this thread is people worrying over slowing growth, but my point is that it isn't a problem, it isn't a sign of failure - it's a sign of moving to the next stage.