Fred Bauder wrote:
Regarding Jimbo: I think it is important that you create an account under some persona, edit some articles, get into an edit war or two, and in general get grounded in the realities of this project.
Peter the Great did it - why not Jimbo?
-- mav
Daniel Mayer wrote:
Fred Bauder wrote:
Regarding Jimbo: I think it is important that you create an account under some persona, edit some articles, get into an edit war or two, and in general get grounded in the realities of this project.
Peter the Great did it - why not Jimbo?
Ah, my hero. ;-)
But, yes, I accept that I should not have spoken so harshly at the beginning.
Here's the problem, basically. My own political opinion in the Israeli/Palestinian situation is not very far from RK's. (I don't know his position in detail, so if it's horrifying, please don't take me to be endorsing that.)
Because of that, I should recuse myself from further deliberations, and offer my apologies to Danny for letting my sympathy for Rk's position to turn into sympathy for RK, which MAY have been warranted or NOT. But that's really no longer for me to decide, since we have an arbitration committee.
--Jimbo
Jimmy Wales wrote:
Daniel Mayer wrote:
Fred Bauder wrote:
Regarding Jimbo: I think it is important that you create an account under some persona, edit some articles, get into an edit war or two, and in general get grounded in the realities of this project.
Peter the Great did it - why not Jimbo?
Ah, my hero. ;-)
Here's the problem, basically. My own political opinion in the Israeli/Palestinian situation is not very far from RK's.
I think that the spirit of Fred's suggestion was to develop trench experience in the edit wars without having the article influenced by the knowledge that you are the one who is editing. The chaos of the Israeli/Palestinian situation would not be a good place to start this. I would suggest something more obscure, where some people might try to make a case for deleting it as not belonging in an encyclopedia. If you are concerned that your political opinions might bleed into the subject and make your chosen persona, then simply choose a less political subject.
Some of this could be a bit trollish, but I've never felt that some controlled use of trolling was all that bad. The important thing when a person uses such a tactic is to know when to stop.
Ec