I need some advice. What should I do when there are two people in the same category with the same name? For instance, if there were two people name Joe Blow and one was a soldier and one an author I could do something like this: Joe Blow (author)|]] and [[Joe Blow (soldier)|]]. But what do I do if they are the same thing.
Here's a real world example, there are two ice hockey players named Petr Sykora. They are both Czech, both have played in the NHL and both are notable enough for an article. Do I make the most notable (he already has an article) [[Petr Sykora]] and the less notable [[Petr Sykora (2)]]? If not, how do I handle this? Thanks.
-Kevin Rector
I need some advice. What should I do when there are two people in the same category with the same name? For instance, if there were two people name Joe Blow and one was a soldier and one an author I could do something like this: Joe Blow (author)|]] and [[Joe Blow (soldier)|]]. But what do I do if they are the same thing.
Here's a real world example, there are two ice hockey players named Petr Sykora. They are both Czech, both have played in the NHL and both are notable enough for an article. Do I make the most notable (he already has an article) [[Petr Sykora]] and the less notable [[Petr Sykora (2)]]? If not, how do I handle this? Thanks.
-Kevin Rector
Do they have a middle name or initial?
Jay.
Well, IMDB does it as [[Petr Sykora (I)]] and [[Petr Sykora (II))]]; their FAQ says that there's no hard and fast rule how they order them, but they try to use one or more of: who is most famous, who came first chronologically, or who is searched for more often. But in this case, why not say [[Petr Sykora (NHL forward)]] and [[Petr Sykora (NHL right wing]]?
jpgordon
On Apr 5, 2005 9:30 AM, JAY JG jayjg@hotmail.com wrote:
I need some advice. What should I do when there are two people in the same category with the same name? For instance, if there were two people name Joe Blow and one was a soldier and one an author I could do something like this: Joe Blow (author)|]] and [[Joe Blow (soldier)|]]. But what do I do if they are the same thing.
Here's a real world example, there are two ice hockey players named Petr Sykora. They are both Czech, both have played in the NHL and both are notable enough for an article. Do I make the most notable (he already has an article) [[Petr Sykora]] and the less notable [[Petr Sykora (2)]]? If not, how do I handle this? Thanks.
-Kevin Rector
Do they have a middle name or initial?
Jay.
WikiEN-l mailing list WikiEN-l@Wikipedia.org http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikien-l
If they have truly identical names, can they be distinguished by their birth year?
Theo
On Tue, 5 Apr 2005 17:26:31 +0100, Kevin Rector wrote:
�I need some advice. What should I do when there are two people in �the
�same category with the same name? For instance, if there were two �people �name Joe Blow and one was a soldier and one an author I could do �something like this: Joe Blow (author)|]] and [[Joe Blow �(soldier)|]]. �But what do I do if they are the same thing.
�Here's a real world example, there are two ice hockey players named �Petr �Sykora. They are both Czech, both have played in the NHL and both �are �notable enough for an article. Do I make the most notable (he �already �has an article) [[Petr Sykora]] and the less notable [[Petr Sykora �(2)]]? If not, how do I handle this? Thanks.
Kevin Rector wrote on 2005/04/05 18:26:
I need some advice. What should I do when there are two people in the same category with the same name? For instance, if there were two people name Joe Blow and one was a soldier and one an author I could do something like this: Joe Blow (author)|]] and [[Joe Blow (soldier)|]]. But what do I do if they are the same thing.
Here's a real world example, there are two ice hockey players named Petr Sykora. They are both Czech, both have played in the NHL and both are notable enough for an article. Do I make the most notable (he already has an article) [[Petr Sykora]] and the less notable [[Petr Sykora (2)]]? If not, how do I handle this? Thanks.
-Kevin Rector
Wiki precedent seems to leave you a pretty free choice. The two authors named Samuel Butler are disambiguated like this:
[[Samuel Butler (1612-1680)]] [[Samuel Butler (1835-1902)]]
But the two poets James Thomson like this, using respectively a principal work and a pseudonym:
[[James Thomson (Seasons)]] [[James Thomson (B.V.)]]
All four of them are quite notable. Either of these systems seems acceptable (I don't much like your 1 and 2 idea), even though the Thomson principle is kind of ad hoc. If you go with the Butler principle, assuming that your players are still alive, I suggest the format
[[Petr Sykora (b. 1980)]]
Bishonen