I don't think you have a right to remove comments on your own RfC. A request for comment is just that: a chance for those both involved and uninvolved to comment on an article or user's situation. [[User:Fawcett5]]'s comments was also at the end of a list, not above signatures. If there is confusion, look at the timestamp on the sigs. That's why we have them.
-Ben
On 10/16/05, actionforum@comcast.net actionforum@comcast.net wrote:
Look again bratsche, you just reverted the page, putting the edits of an uninvolved user, over the signatures of 4 people.
It doesn't matter what excuse redwolf24 used, he is an involved admin, he'd already reached the conclusions below yesterday per his "outside" view on the page. Note that he gave no edits or specifics in support of his "view" either.
You might want to note also, that 172 went to his talk page about this issue, right after voting for him for bureaucrat. -- Silverback
-------------- Original message --------------
First off, we need get the facts straight here. The block log shows not
a
3RR violation, but something else. Let's take a look:
18:22, October 16, 2005 Redwolf24blocked " User:Silverback " with an expiry time of 24 hours (reverts incessantly, removing information from
his
RfC , has been attacking 172 a lot lately, hasn't been too civil, hopefully
this
block will turn him around.)
This doesn't seem to be much of a 3RR block, but more of a block for disruption, violating [[WP:NPA]], and removing comments from the RfC
without
reason.
--[[:en:User:Bratsche|Ben]]
On 10/16/05, actionforum@comcast.net wrote:
Redwolf24 just blocked me, allegedly for 3RR on the RfC page against me where he had taken a voting position against me. We really need to develop a fair process.
-- Bratsche-It means "viola!" _______________________________________________ WikiEN-l mailing list WikiEN-l@Wikipedia.org To unsubscribe from this mailing list, visit: http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikien-l
WikiEN-l mailing list WikiEN-l@Wikipedia.org To unsubscribe from this mailing list, visit: http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikien-l
-- Bratsche-It means "viola!"