From: Stan Shebs stanshebs@earthlink.net Reply-To: English Wikipedia wikien-l@Wikipedia.org Date: Wed, 27 Dec 2006 13:18:04 -0800 To: English Wikipedia wikien-l@Wikipedia.org Subject: Re: [WikiEN-l] The boundaries of OR (contd)
Marc Riddell wrote:
I did not mean to suggest that only 'experts' should be able to edit in WP. My suggestion is that those who are able to edit provide some clue as to their background and areas of interest that could lead a reasonable (yes. I used the word) person to accept what they have edited as credible.
OK then, this suggestion is only meaningful if you're talking about a "may edit" bit, presumably set by admins upon receipt of - what? Does a college sophomore have to send in physical proof of their major? Are college freshmen never allowed to edit anything except Pokemon? :-) I have no formal credentials in naval history, but my personal library is larger and deeper than that of the local university, so I likely have more and better citeable sources than a random nonspecialist history professor at that university. On the other hand, maybe I have all these books, but don't understand them, or as more commonly happens (to other people :-) ), I've developed bizarre theories. What about professors who develop bizarre theories that they can't get published, so they try to push them into WP? Are they credible editors? Their background will likely look pretty good.
In practice, what's more important to know is whether editors have enough sense to know whether they are relying on sources they have, or are adding material with no solid basis in fact. It's a behavioral thing that no credential or bio bit helps me with, only past experience on WP.
Stan
Stan,
Back to some basics of my argument, or proposal, or whatever it has become: I am not talking about 'experts'. If I see an edit has been made to an Article in WP I would like to be able go to that Article's History Page and see the 'source' (person) of that edit, with a User Name in Blue. Then, if I choose, I can go to that corresponding User Page and learn something about that editor - it really is that simple!
Marc
WikiEN-l mailing list WikiEN-l@Wikipedia.org To unsubscribe from this mailing list, visit: http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikien-l