On 5/24/07, Ken Arromdee arromdee@rahul.net wrote:
That's too specific. It may reveal a surprise fact (the identity of Valen, for instance) that is not an ending, or it may reveal something that is part of an ending but not an ending in itself.
How can a tag be too specific? If it's inappropriate for some particular use, make a different tag. The whole problem with the spoiler tags at the moment is they're not specific enough: are they revealing a massive surprise ending, or are they telling you the plot of Wind in the Willows? Specific tags for specific situations would resolve a lot of the complaints, such as David Gerard's about WWII - there would presumably be no specific tag to cover that situation, because it's an absurd situation that doesn't need a tag.
Steve