Date: Wed, 12 Sep 2012 11:07:03 -0600 (MDT) From: "Fred Bauder" fredbaud@fairpoint.net Subject: Re: [WikiEN-l] VIP Treatment
why should they bother politely pointing someone to OTRS, much less spend time and effort trying to be diplomatic themselves?
Sxeptomaniac
Because they are decent capable people, take pride in doing a good job, and are concerned about the accuracy and reputation of Wikipedia.
Fred
on 9/12/12 2:58 PM, Matthew Jacobs at sxeptomaniac@gmail.com wrote:
Oh really? So why do we have to desysop admins? Were they "misusing their tools" in a "decent capable" way? Was it part of "doing a good job"? Were they desysopped for being "concerned about the accuracy and reputation of Wikipedia"?
I can understand if you think I'm overstating the problem, but I find it ridiculous that you would deny the obvious: some people are drawn to adminship for the wrong reasons, and some maybe even for the right reasons, but choose to act on them in a short-sighted way. No RFA process, no matter how good, will ever be able to fully weed out people who really shouldn't be admins. The problem is, WP has no mechanism for dealing with those who turn out to not exemplify what an administrator should be, but stop short of actually breaking rules.
Sxeptomaniac
Agreed. But how could such a mechanism be created given the existing structure of the Project?
marc Riddell