On 11/2/05, Puddl Duk puddlduk@gmail.com wrote:
Case in point, DrBob is a good editor. <snip> His admin nomination is being torpedoed because he "doesn't interact enough", despite the fact that he has been a volunteer on the wikipedia reference desks for over two years. Not only does he occasionally seek out interaction, but he is good at it.
This is the most idiotic no vote I've ever seen at RFA.
(cut lots of stuff I agree with for the sake of brevity).
That's saying a lot, given that I recently went through RFA to vote (having not done so for some time) and was appalled at the idiocy being practiced and petty objections being expressed.
It's especially distubing since being treated like that has driven off many good contributors in the past.
-Matt (User:Morven)