On 9/14/05, Stan Shebs shebs@apple.com wrote:
What do you think constitutes evidence? I've already said that I'm not lending my experience and knowledge of WP to evaluating the worthiness of articles because of the way the process works. I'm not so egotistical as to claim that my absence from AfD materially damages WP, but the last time I looked (a while ago) people were making mistakes that I could have corrected.
Examples would be a perfect place to start. There appear to be two main criticisms of AfD:
1. Unreliability. This appears to be your point. 2. Bad and unhealthy atmosphere.
I would appreciate (from anyone) evidence for either of these. Despite all the comments about AfD's foibles and failings, I personally have not seen them in action.
These comments are not intended to be difficult. I am just not currently certain why changes need to be made.
Yours, Sam