David Gerard wrote:
On 19/02/07, Rich Holton richholton@gmail.com wrote:
Just curious...would [[List of people taller than eight feet]] be OR?
Not with good refs IMO. Might include arguably famous near-misses. [[Longest novel]] takes some judgement calls, and there are books that were advertised as "longest novel since ..." that are nothing like a longest-novel contender. But editorial judgement in the cause of usefulness is not OR except for an extreme black-and-white thinker.
- d.
I agree. So does the real conflict come in having a subjective article name (using "tall") for an article that is using an objective criteria?
-Rich