Delirium wrote:
Oskar Sigvardsson wrote:
This is somewhat off-topic, but I'd like to remind all of you hard-working stiffs who do nothing all day but argue over tiny points of wikipedia policy and generally spends your day fighting other editors to check out the comments left by those who have donated:
Some of us are busy, you know, actually writing an encyclopedia. Comparing your edit history to mine, I would say you aren't particularly active in that area, lately, and so aren't in a good position to throw stones.
Does [[WP:NPA]] not apply to the mailing list and these sorts of snide attacks on other editors are now permitted? I'd like to request Oskar be put on moderation, please.
What personal attack is there in what you quote? No individual is mentioned, and he makes a completely valid criticism that applies to a wide range of individuals. Contrariwise, your response specifically criticizes Oskar. Which is more characteristic of a personal attack? If you really want Oskar to be moderated you should also be asking that the powers that be apply whatever may be the policy in a fair and uniform manner.
The rest of Oskar's message was very positive, and said far more good about the comments that contributors were making.
Ec