Look at Eric's reply. It never changed. I don't see any reason to strip someone from their admin powers for enforcing the rules.
--Mgm
On 5/9/05, Richard Rabinowitz rickyrab@eden.rutgers.edu wrote:
No offense, but I thought this was a 3RR rule - 3 reverts and revisions on a page. Since when did it go to 5 reverts/24 h?
On Sun, 8 May 2005, Leif Knutsen wrote:
User:Jtdirl blocked me (Leifern) for allegedly violating the 5 reverts in 24 hour rule. This is both unreasonable and an abuse of his admin privileges, for the following reasons:
- There are actually 4 reverts in about 4 hours
- The reversions were of deletions of graphs - since it's simply not possible to reword images, I had little option besides reverting the deletions
- The person who kept deleting the graphs did very little to justify them besides saying that they were irrelevant
- My adversary (Geni, also an admin) reverted three times, but this apparently didn't bother Jtdirl
- Jtdirl has an axe to grind - we had an editing dispute that he lost about heirs apparent - I can't help but think this is a vindictive act.
- Jtdirl gave no warning, made no effort to mediate, simply went ahead and blocked
I don't know what the remedy for this is, but I would propose that both Jtdirl and Geni lose their admin privileges. If I am not unblocked immediately, I am happy to find another hobby. I believe my contributions speak for themselves - that would be a great loss for the WP community. _______________________________________________ WikiEN-l mailing list WikiEN-l@Wikipedia.org http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikien-l
WikiEN-l mailing list WikiEN-l@Wikipedia.org http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikien-l