On Apr 24, 2006, at 3:57 PM, Brian Salter-Duke wrote:
Now clearly Huck is a dick, but do either the barnstars or saving a deleted article on his user page count as vandalism? It is clearly an attack on me as if people see I have awarded barnstars to this dickhead, they will likely think I am a dickhead.
It's a personal attack, and claiming other people said things they didn't. Both of these are quite enough to revert the pages in question (protecting them if he continues to revert back) and blocking if it continues. Block under the reason of "disruption". IMO. I'm not going to get involved, because I have a general policy of ignoring Wikipedia dicks; but that's what I'd suggest to one of our admins more willing to handle such things. It's not vandalism, though - that really only refers to "joe is gay" type of stuff. Personal attacks, such as this, are something else.
Jesse Weinstein