Steve Bennett wrote:
Notability at the fact level is even harder to determine than notability at the subject level. Ask a republican whether Bush's alleged administrative adventures in the National Guard were "notable". Ask a Democrat the same.
--- Jimmy Wales jwales@wikia.com wrote:
But I still might agree with your basic point, that notability at the fact level is harder to determine that notability at the subject level.
Or to put it another way: Should there be a WP:FAME policy? Not to be too much of a smart alec, but this thread is about "defamation" after all. To be fair, in my criticism I may have been confusing WP:OFFICE, WP:LIBEL, and WP:BIO, and wound up somehow blending all of these together.
So its good IMHO to see that people here have *finally* been able to re-spin WP:BIO in terms of NPOV, rather than making all of these references to LAWSUIT and CUDDLE, which were entirely confusing.
Once again the criticism has helped to clarify the message.
- Stevertigo
__________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com