On 6/17/06, George Herbert george.herbert@gmail.com wrote:
You seem to think that AFD is a big joke because we have bad articles surviving. My point, and several others point, is that we have bad articles on appropriate encyclopedic topics survive AFD, and my argument is that that's entirely proper since we should be doing cleanups on them instead of arguing about deleting them. When you
Right. If we deleted all the "bad" articles on Wikipedia, it'd be a much smaller place. We should only delete the "inappropriate" articles: unnoteworthy or unencyclopaedic subjects, and the odd copyvio or defamation.
Steve