On Jan 16, 2007, at 9:00 AM, Jeff Raymond wrote:
Hardly. The argument by the delete voters was that it was non- notable. Our own "notability" criteria regarding web content says otherwise. Either a guideline is widely accepted, or it is not, and the only worthwhile close here would have been to keep it.
And it should be noted, the closing admin is a long-standing opponent of that notability guideline who explicitly used his closure as an occasion to declare it dead. This is NOT acceptable practice.
-Phil