Rebecca wrote:
I swear, this whole discussion is making me want to follow you out of Wikipedia.
I have no idea why we tolerate this growing group of idiots who just camp out on wikien-l and VFD with some sort of problem with authority. I just saw one of them (who has barely made any edits to the main namespace in the last fortnight) seriously suggest that admins should be desysopped for as little as a snide remark. I'm getting really sick of this.
Sorry, I should have read Alphax's post more closely before hastily agreeing to part of it. Of course admins do a great job, they're dedicated to Wikipedia and passionate about its cause, for the most part they stick to the rules and strive for community consensus in everything they do. There have been cases where admins have violated policy, lashing out in the heat of the moment, and I think those cases call for punishment in proportion to the crime.
In this particular case, I don't think Silsor is guilty of any crime apart from bruising a fragile ego.
-- Tim Starling