Matthew Brown wrote:
- Attempts to engage this user in discussion have been utterly and
completely ignored. Possibly out of simply not understanding Wikipedia all that well.
Well, to me, that's pretty important. It's hard to find a satisfactory common ground if he won't even log in and answer questions or contribute to the discussion in any way.
I must confess a little bit of bias against a user who doesn't create a username and doesn't engage in discussion. In the spirit of Assume Good Faith, I will presume that these have been due to lack of knowledge of the way Wikipedia works.
Yes, I agree with all of that -- both the little bit of bias, and the assumption of good faith.
I am certainly not anti her point; I am against some of the ways she is presenting her case, and would like to work with her to make the articles as fair and accurate as we can.
Should I email her directly, do you think?
Yes, I think that would be delightful.
--Jimbo