JAY JG wrote:
From: Tony Sidaway f.crdfa@gmail.com
On 12/9/05, Keith Old keithold@gmail.com wrote:
If we got rid of AfD, we'd have to sort through the Deletion logs,
Only for a short while. After a few waggy fingers and blocks, the administrators performing inappropriate out-of-process deletions would stop. Trust me on this. Calvinball.
Here's an even better idea; let's not mess with something that's working reasonably well.
Assumption of fact not in evidence. AFD is not working reasonably well. Deletion of pages is one thing; the current culture of AFD is utterly poisonous to the community and has an appalling tendency to assumption of bad faith, *especially* when anyone dares question how it currently works. (wikien-l is apparently regarded as an enemy of AFD now. Goodness!) I believe there's an arbitration case on at the moment concerning precisely this atmosphere of bad faith perpetuated on AFD.
- d.