Jon wrote:
I wasn't proposing another guideline on Relevancy - and I agree there'd be no point in having one. We'd never agree on a definition anyway. Relevancy is an issue, though - what to include and exclude from any given article (call it notability or something else if you wish).
Yeah. I left notability carefully undefined.
The problem with the cancerous proliferation of guidelines and policy on en: is that people keep trying to legislate cluefulness.
Come the end of the day, commonsense, or editorial judgment as David refers to it as, can't be legislated for. But we do need good editors to fight the fight on controversial subjects to make commonsense prevail.
I think we've got lots of those ;-) That's why I emphasised right up top that the goal is to get it *right*.
- d.