I don't know what others think, but I feel the mailing list discussion on this whole AFD issue isn't structured. Lot of people are sharing their opinion, but after a few days of discussion we still don't seem to get to a middle ground.
By organizing a discussion structured as a compact "finding of the facts", I hope to find out where our opinions differ so we can address them directly.
Please visit my discussion page where I have up a few points on what I see the current state of AFD. Please join in:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:MacGyverMagic/Deletion/Reform
Mgm