On Thursday 12 February 2004 01:07 pm, Poor, Edmund W wrote:
Jimbo and Larry's NPOV policy does not say that right and wrong are to be decided by the individual. It says (and this is a crucial distinction) that when matters of fact are in dispute, the Wikipedia won't endorse one side as correct. It also says that Wikipedia won't endorse one philosophical or religious viewpoint as correct. Same with moral or ethical judgments.
In the first sentence, do you use "right" and "wrong" in the context of morality, or in the context of truth? If the former, then I disagree with that sentence - If the latter, then I agree with it.
(I'd also be more interested to hear your take on the arguments I made against your position, and not those of some website) :)
Best, Sascha Noyes