On Sat, 1 Dec 2007 13:04:43 -0500, Anthony wikimail@inbox.org wrote:
I don't think private has to be synonymous with secret to call these lists secret. In fact, I've said myself that I think there is a difference between a private list and a secret list, and that I feel these lists were both. The email itself says things like "The one thing I have to ask is that you all be very tight lipped about this." and "Foremost, please keep mum!" And what is probably the smoking gun, which has nothing directly to do with her libel of !!, is the comment that "They [Wikipedia Review] don't know this list exists."
Durova is not in any way representative of the members of that list.
Guy (JzG)