Stevertigo said: [more than would make sense to reprint]
I agree with pretty much everything in that mail. I do see the point and idea behind Cleanup, it's a valid premise... it's just the implementation that's bad. I'm no fan of anonymity... I've got a strange and dodgy memory, and without identities to associate comments with, it becomes much harder to remember them. Hm. Three days on (a heavily remodeled) Cleanup, if it hasn't been rewritten, refactored, or merged enough to be satisfactory, it goes onto VFD for, say, another 3 days? Just a thought... I can see approval for anything with a decent title... too often, there's issues about articles on VFD because they're at the wrong title or because there's something that has no relevance but a good title... hm. It's something to think about.
-- Jake