Nathan Russell wrote in part:
I do disagree with RK calling anyone he dislikes a Nazi, but that's a separate issue. If I told (picking random user names here) Angela that I thought she was a terrorist because she protected an article on someone else's version, would that justify Uncle Ed telling me he was a terrorist and was going to kill me?
You're analogy goes too far here -- and that's rather the point.
Would it justify Uncle Ed telling you he was a terrorist, *period*? No, it wouldn't -- but Sascha was claiming more than that MNH was unjust. Then, would it be reasonable for us to /conclude/ that Uncle Ed /meant/ (but did *not* literally say!) that he was going to kill you?
IMO, that would not be a reasonable conclusion.
-- Toby