On Mon, 19 Nov 2007, David Goodman wrote:
That is saying we should report whatever a reviewer says, rather than whatever of it is encyclopedic. If 5 reviewers put spoilers in 5 different places, do we include all of them?
Only if we're quoting the reviewers' entire reviews. Since our article is probably not going to be exactly like each reviewer's article, even in structure (let alone in actual words), we need not put spoiler warnings in the exact same places, if "the exact same places" is even meaningful considering that it's a review and not an encyclopedia article.