On 5/21/07, John Lee johnleemk@gmail.com wrote:
The problem, as I and others have raised, is that defining a spoiler is extremely difficult to do without violating [[WP:NOR]]. How do we know what a spoiler is? You may just know it, but your subjective judgment will obviously differ from others, and without a source we can turn to, there's no way we can agree on what a spoiler is.
Oh, come on. That argument assumes we're mostly mindless idiots, or that we don't share any common language or culture. In most cases it's obvious whether something is a spoiler or not.
Part of "Assume Good Faith" is to assume your fellow editors are humans.