[sent to wikien-l and wikimedia-l]
http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/En_validation_topics#Consolidated_proposal
This is a fantastic piece of work from [[User:Beland]], who has taken the assorted rambling proposals elsewhere on that page and put them into a form with half a chance of people bothering to fill it out sensibly.
The only problem I can see is whether people will bother filling in that many questions. OTOH, this is the experimental phase. (What a useful excuse that is ;-)
Since this is a very useful piece of work and saves others (e.g. me) from doing the job of making sense of this stuf, you can assume the thing at http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/En_validation_topics#Response_page is more or less what will be visible when people hit the tab marked "Validate" (or "Rate this page" or translation thereof), at least on en:.
So please look through it and flag any serious problems you see with it (other than sheer length) and if any attributes could be reasonably cut.
- d.