Snowspinner wrote
And what on Earth does it mean to be notable outside its community? For a webcomic to be notable outside its own fans? Outside of webcomics fans in general?
I have no difficulty at all assenting to the idea that VfD can get it wrong - happens daily, I imagine. I think we should be concerned if any area is treated with inherent prejudice, and this may be a prime example.
The way these points are posed, though, suggests weaknesses elsewhere. If there are awards, ratings, a community voice, document them on WP first. That is, develop the supporting articles on webcomics, so that those articles posted do not appear simply to be URLs in a vacuum of context.
Charles