Phil Sandifer wrote:
If VfD is becoming unwieldy, why not split it into some topical pages. VfD-Popular Culture, VfD-Sciences, VfD-Humanities, VfD-Politics, etc. That would lighten the load on the single page.
I've had a similar thought but on a different basis. The most controversial criterion by far has been notability/encyclopedic. Why not simply split off "VfD-Notability". Perhaps other criteria could be split off later too if one begins to dominate the discussions.
Ec