On 21/05/07, Oskar Sigvardsson oskarsigvardsson@gmail.com wrote:
On 5/21/07, David Gerard dgerard@gmail.com wrote:
How closely it reflects popularity is questionable. That is, "of articles people went looking for in Wikipedia, the top 100 are ..." We don't know that this chart reflects that. So it may be of interest with quite a grain of salt.
I'm sure that the script uses good statistical methods to calculate error. The accuracy is displayed right there in the list, with the margin of error. It rises fairly quickly, but the top ten articles all stay under 10%, and I think we can be fairly certain that those do, in fact, represent the most viewed pages of wikipedia.
I'm not questioning the stats - I'm questioning that those accurately represent what people want to look up on Wikipedia. Are wikis really such a popular subject? Or do people type "wiki [subject]" into Google? How many of the porn hits are from people looking for porn and disappointed to end up at a text page?
- d.