On 4/19/07, Slim Virgin slimvirgin@gmail.com wrote:
Can you answer my previous question, Erik, because it's one that a lot of people are now worried about. Is it your view that all that matters is what users do on-wiki, and that what they do to other users off-wiki is of no consequence?
Brandt's main complaint is about the existence and content of his biography. As far as I understand, he only intends to comment on the talk page of that biography to ask for corrections he considers important. Granting him that limited "right to response" seems to be something we ought to consider completely irrespective of all other ongoing disputes.
Would you be less concerned about the unblock if we effectively limited his editing privileges to Talk:Daniel Brandt?