James Hare wrote:
Hi all,
I have an idea for PROD. You know when someone PRODs an article, and then the PROD tag is removed, you have to then take it to AFD because the author of the article doesn't want the article to be deleted? Well, I think that in order for the PROD to be justifably removed, the author *must* state an acceptable (at the very least) reason that the article shouldn't be PRODed. If it's acceptable-at-the-very-least, then it can be taken to AFD. If there's no reason or the reason given is not reasonable (for example, if the stated reason was "Because Jimbo has a beard"), then the removal can be reverted.
There's no requirement that someone give a reason for prodding, why require a reason for removal?
Also, it doesn't *have* to go to AfD.
-Jeff