On 1/28/06, Haukur Þorgeirsson haukurth@hi.is wrote:
The problem is that some people treat the process oriented requests as content-oriented and say: "No, we won't undelete it - it doesn't look like a worthwhile article to me." And some people treat the content-oriented requests as process-oriented and say: "No, we can't undelete it because the AfD was legit."
This is not good, DRV has to be able to handle both types of requests sensibly.
No. We should never restore crap content, no matter how mucked up the process was that deleted it, and we should always restore good content, no matter how perfectly the process that deleted it was followed.
Anything else is putting process before the encyclopedia.