Reason 1: "Provocative list" - This seems like the one valid reason for a block, but this interprets the issue as one of a direct personal attack against individuals, which is unclear, as others have mentioned. Even if it were, such attacks are outside of Wikipedia, and therefore cant be dealt with through our formal process. Does Slim feel she is in a position to impose informal process? Reason 2: "Seems to be staging a major disruption" - As Matt pointed out (the only one apparently), the user in question has also admonished people to adhere to NPOV. It would at least be interesting if those of that particular right-wing extremist orientation can actually adhere to NPOV, but the block sanctions a prejudice toward the contrary. Reason 3: "Claims elsewhere that this (his userpage?) is his homepage" - Doesnt seem to have much weight at all. Reason 4: "Block was inline with IAR (ignore all rules)" - IAR trumps real policy?
SV
____________________________________________________ Start your day with Yahoo! - make it your home page http://www.yahoo.com/r/hs