On 3/8/06, Stan Shebs shebs@apple.com wrote:
Mark Wagner wrote:
To get an idea as to what sort of image tagging is currently being used, I did a survey of the license tags applied to the 2000 most recent images uploaded (which represents about 24 hours and 20 minutes of uploading). Of those images, 134 were duplicate uploads or otherwise not accounted for, leaving 1,866 images to check for tags. The detailed results are at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Carnildo/upload_stats
For 1,866 images uploaded, 2,014 license tags were applied:
745 images were tagged as some sort of "fair use". The vast majority used one of the boilerplate templates, with most of the images being tagged as screenshots, covers, logos, and promotional images. Only 26 generic "fair use" tags were used, with most of them being "fair use in".
This is good news actually! Boilerplates can be handled en masse with tools as we improve our policy. It's the generic tags that require the one-by-one manual evaluation.
The only tag that can be handled completely automatically is {{fairusein}} -- such images can be removed from any article they don't have a tag for. All the other tags require human evaluation to decide if the tag is applied correctly ({{promophoto}} and {{promotional}} are frequently applied to any image found on official or fan websites) and decide if the image is being used in a way that the template allows.
It would be interesting to retain the list of images and then see what's happened to them a month from now. Empirically I've noticed that a lot of fair use images are uploaded for articles that are soon deleted, and are in turn deleted because they are orphans. I wouldn't be surprised if most of the day's non-free uploads were gone after a month or two.
I've got the list. The problem is that my program collecting the statistics didn't distinguish between deleted images and those with blank image description pages. I noticed that the images with more...interesting...titles (Image:Hentai - Pokemon - May, Misty & Ash (1) (1).jpg, anyone?) tended to be deleted quickly, though.
-- Mark [[User:Carnildo]]