Throughout life, any policy of judging people by their success in working well with others, is a blank cheque for bullying and for it to win.
Oh, perhaps. But working well with others is critical to a person's success in a collaborative process like Wikipedia. Nobody gives a rat's ass what you're like in the "real world"; you may be an incredibly skilled or talented person with a huge amount to offer the world -- but if you can't work well collaboratively in the context of Wikipedia, then you'll run into a wall of utter resistance on Wikipedia. It's hardly bullying when you come to a place when you come to a place where cooperation is required by the community, refuse to cooperate, and are ostracized.
Any "judging" that has occurred has to be understood as applying only within the context of the universe of Wikipedia editors.
jpgordon http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Jpgordon*∇∆∇∆*