Stan Shebs wrote:
Abe Sokolov wrote:
Re: "Hey - let's all calm down and take a deep breath. Now please be nice to one another!" -- mav
I'm already calm, so I don't need to take a deep breath. I'm just sitting here at my desk, kind of tired after not getting much sleep, looking over some papers and research, checking e-mail in various accounts, checking news sites, and the like.
But I am fed up with Wikipedia, though, and especially people like Stan and Fred. I doubt that I'll be able to be nice to either of them until they stop spreading these lies about me being a Stalinist...
I've never said you were a Stalinist. I do think you're heavily biased; you always have an excuse or apology for a leftwinger's action, and are always ready to blame a rightwinger for engaging in exactly the same kinds of actions. As it happens, there's a strain of academic history for which this degree of bias is considered normal, and another strain on the rightwing side too; an unfortunate state of affairs. It's gotten so bad these days that you can't usefully read anything on 20th-century history before finding out the left/right bias of the writer.
I agree that you weren't the one to introduce the term Stalinist. It can be difficult to steer a middle course between the blind idealism of the left, and the blind realism of the right.
Ec