Steve Summit wrote:
Nonsense. Notability ain't pregnancy.
It's closer to pregnancy than some fleeting thing. Keep in mind - Wikipedia notability has nothing to do with real world notability, so we need to keep it, uh, in-universe. If we say "notability is x," we can't then turn around and say that there's "borderline" - it doesn't, shouldn't, and won't fly.
Want to remove "borderline" cases? Try to get consensus at WP:BIO.
-Jeff