On 21/11/2007, joshua.zelinsky@yale.edu joshua.zelinsky@yale.edu wrote:
The reason people are engaging in this rhetoric is because a) they are worried that something like the Making Lights matter will occur again and b) the Black matter is only a difference of degree, not of kind. The same result occurs- the advocacy of removal of material that would be linked to but for the fact that it contains information about Wikipedians.
Indeed. Not addressing the concerns, or claiming "it's all BADSITES and that's dead" or equivalent, does not make the concerns go away.
- d.