On 14/04/06, Matt Brown morven@gmail.com wrote:
I disagree with removing everything that has a natural qualifier, since people may not know or think of the correct one. E.g. if someone is searching for a city named Victoria, they may not know what state, province, county or whatever it's in.
It makes sense to list the more likely cases first, though.
Several possibilities: 1 List only true ambiguities, point all others to a subpage ("things called Victoria") 2 List true ambiguities first, followed by "other things with the word Victoria in them" 3 List true ambiguities and things called Victoria all mixed in together (current strategy)
I would tend to agree that strategy 2 is better.
Also note that I'm obviously talking about a general strategy for big disambig pages, not just the Victoria page :)
Steve