On 4/20/06, Oskar Sigvardsson oskarsigvardsson@gmail.com wrote:
Minor correction: even the ArbComm cannot impose an indefinite ban.
Don't let the issue here get buried under discussion of OFFICE. The issue is that Danny, while apparently acting as a common or garden variety admin, -- and not just without discussion, but rather while /actively refusing to discuss/ -- imposed a lifetime ban from Wikipedia.
Indefinite block.
While /actively refusing to discuss/.
Precisely. Trying to defend Danny's desysopping and ban by crying wheel-war is just wikilawyering in my opinion.
I don't know about wikilawyering, but at the very least, it shows an inconsistent use and enforcement of WP:OFFICE and normal admin actions.