On 6/21/06, geni geniice@gmail.com wrote:
It is also the top result on google for Biaxial nematic. At the moment we have rather a nice motivator for people to add stuff to it. Add stuff and it will be the top hit on google. People will see it. If you instead say add stuff and people may see it if and when a reviewer gets round to looking at it (which will be a while since the number of people we have who understand the subject is probably somewhat limited) you have lost that motivation.
The idea of "quality protection", like regular protection or semi-protection, is that only a small percentage of articles would behave in that fashion. 99% of articles would continue to be immediately editable, and simply inform the reader of the availability of reviewed versions.
Erik