geni wrote:
On 9/14/05, Bryan Derksen bryan.derksen@shaw.ca wrote:
geni wrote:
See WP:CP for why that isn't even legal.
We're discussing an alternative to VfD/AfD. Copyright problems is a completely different matter, handled by a different process. I don't see the relevance or connection between the two.
Really? you don't see how PWD would affect something that has to do with deletion?
If PWD was being proposed as a way of dealing with copyright violations, then yes, of course there would be a major problem there.
But it's _not_ being proposed. We don't have to use the same approach to deletion in every single circumstance where things "need to be removed from Wikipedia". PWD is being proposed as an alternative to the administrative deletion that's currently being used by the VfD/AfD process. I haven't proposed using it to deal with copyright violations, and as far as I'm aware nobody else has either (until you did just now, that is). Have you seen a proposal along those lines that I've missed?