On 12/9/05, MacGyverMagic/Mgm macgyvermagic@gmail.com wrote:
It's simply impossible to not use deletion. Some subjects will always be contentious and need discussion instead of a speedy criterion to cover them.
Mgm
Maybe you could give a few examples of such subjects, preferably from AfD? I can't think of anything that's verifiable and a noun and shouldn't at least be kept as a redirect.
Pottercast/PotterCast (and podcasts in general) Forums and Blogs Bands (C-Moon - German, is it vanity or not?) Schools (examples shouldn't be needed for this one), although I have to admit discussion is pretty much growing on this. I'm sure this will eventually lead to notability guidelines.
All these could be covered by some number statistic and notability guidelines, but a quick test to easily determine its deletion worthiness is much harder. Doesn't mean we shouldn't try to find one, though.