On Mon, 21 Feb 2005 00:10:52 -0000 (GMT), Tony Sidaway minorityreport@bluebottle.com wrote:
Zoney said:
Nope. I will not accept anyone's right to express Nazi views.
Wikipedia is probably the wrong place for you. We don't do advocacy but we do give expression to all significant views.>
Seemingly though, you find it unacceptable for me to have the view that some views are unacceptable. Evidently there are limits to what views even you can accept.
Is this a plural "you"? I think you will find that your view can also be expressed, but not advocated on Wikipedia. We adopt the neutral point of view here.
No we don't give expression to all significant views. We write about them - but we don't attempt to get the reader to emphasise with them.
Possibly one or both of us have merely mis-interpreted the others meaning. I am in no way suggesting that Nazism shouldn't be written about down to the last detail in Wikipedia. (Any sensible person will see it for what it is, just as with [[Xenu]]). But I do not consider that people should be allowed to express a Nazi POV on Wikipedia (not just in articles - but generally speaking) or anywhere else.
Oh - and could you dispense with the condescending attitude?
Zoney